New Legislators Join Avalanche of Opposition to Daughters Sale to Prime

[Dec. 2, 2014] OAKLAND, Calif. – Four newly elected members of the California Legislature have added their names to the rush of opposition to the sale of Daughters of Charity Health System to Prime Healthcare.

Previously, three U.S. Representatives, 42 current and former state legislators, mayors, county officials, labor unions and community organizations from across California have expressed deep concerns about the sale. The new Assemblymembers opposing the sale are: Connie Leyva (D-Pacoima), David Chiu (D-San Francisco), Kansen Chu (D-San Jose), and Patrick O’Donnell (D-Long Beach).

It is the largest group of state legislators in history to oppose the sale of private hospitals in California. Here is a list of the current and former legislators who have raised concerns about the sale:

Last First District Last First District Last First District
Cooley Ken AD08 Holden Chris AD41 Hill Jerry SD13
Levine Marc AD10 Gatto Mike AD43 Beall Jim SD15
Frazier Jim AD11 Hernandez Roger AD48 Monning William SD17
Eggman-Talamantes Susan AD13 Gomez Jimmy AD51 Leyva Connie SD20
Bonilla Susan AD14 Rodriquez Freddie AD52 Hernandez Ed SD22
Chiu David AD17 Calderon Ian AD57 Pavley Fran SD27
Bonta Rob AD18 Garcia Cristina AD58 Lara Ricardo SD33
Ting Philip AD19 Jones-Sawyer Reginald AD59 Skinner Nancy AD15
Quirk Bill AD20 Rendon Anthony AD63 Fox Steve AD36
Mullin Kevin AD22 O’Donnell Patrick AD70 Bocanegra Raul AD39
Chu Kansan AD25 Atkins Toni AD78 Pérez John AD53
Campos Nora AD27 Gonzalez Lorena AD80 Perez V. Manuel AD56
Stone Mark AD29 Galgianni Cathleen SD05 Hall III Isadore AD64
Alejo Luis AD30 Pan Richard SD06 Lowenthal Bonnie AD70
Perea Henry AD31 Wieckowski Bob SD10 Evans Noreen SD02
Williams Das AD37

Others opposed to the sale are San Francisco Mayor Ed Lee, Santa Clara County Executive Jeff Smith, the City of Lynwood, the mayors of Bell and Huntington Beach, and city councilmembers from Compton, Commerce, Montebello and Bell Gardens. The San Jose Mercury News is against the sale, as are eight labor unions: California School Employees Association, UFCW Western States Council, Los Angeles County Federation of Labor, United Nurses Associations of California (AFSCME), SEIU California, SEIU Local 721, Orange County Employees Association and Scientists & Engineers Local 20. The Chamber of Commerce from Florence-Firestone is also against the sale.

In addition, several elected officials have publicly expressed their concerns about selling the hospitals to Prime Healthcare: U.S. Reps. Janice Hahn (D-San Pedro) and Xavier Becerra (D-Los Angeles), Los Angeles County Supervisor Mark Ridley-Thomas and Santa Clara County Supervisors Cindy Chavez, Dave Cortese and Ken Yeager.

Daughters of Charity announced Oct. 10 that it chose Prime Healthcare as the lead bidder for the safety-net hospital system and would negotiate with Prime exclusively. Concern lies with Prime Healthcare’s dismal record and business practices:

  • Prime admitted that it is under federal investigation for allegedly overbilling the federal government;
  • Prime paid $370,000 in federal and state fines after deliberately violating a patient’s privacy by sharing her records with journalists and 800 employees;
  • A group of doctors in San Bernardino County sued Prime Healthcare last year when the company denied them access to their own patients;
  • The company’s Desert Valley Hospital was sanctioned by the California Department of Public Health for improper care resulting in a patient’s death; and
  • Prime’s Garden Grove hospital was cited by the State of California after a patient was administered a lethal dose of a powerful sedative.

Daughters of Charity owns Seton Medical Center, Daly City; Seton Coastside, Moss Beach; O’Connor Hospital, San Jose; Saint Louise Regional Hospital, Gilroy; St. Vincent Medical Center, Los Angeles; and St. Francis Medical Center, Lynwood.

Comments are closed.